One of the very first posts I wrote here at Feeding on Christ had to do with the doctrine of justification by faith alone and the time element. The most significant passage of Scripture in this discussion, and yet one that is often overlooked, is Romans 4:10. In the context, the apostle Paul is explaining the nature of justification by faith alone from the example of Abraham. Citing the locus classicus, Gen. 15:16 repeatedly, Paul develops his argumentation based on the application of the covenant sign to Abraham. In one short passage, Paul posits justification at a specific point in time. He asks, “How then was it counted to him? Was it before or after he had been circumcised?” The answer is richer than most have acknowledged. Paul replies, “It was not after, but before he was circumcised.” The apostle eliminates the possibility of understanding justification as occurring “after” Abraham was circumcised. There are actually two lessons we can learn from this. Interestingly, most commentators focus only on the first implication.
(1) The Jews do not have any special privilege above the Gentiles after the death, burial, and resurrection of Christ. (2) Abraham was justified at a particular point in time, as is true of those who believe after Abraham. He was not counted righteous after circumcision but before he was circumcised. We must make clear that there is no future imputation of righteousness. How (i.e. when) was Abraham justified, while circumcised or while uncircumcised? Not while circumcised but while uncircumcised.

This is really good. Love it.
One question though: When you wrote:
“He was not counted righteous after circumcision not before he was circumcised. ”
I’m sure I know what you mean but is the above statement worded correctly? Should it be instead: (changing the 2nd not to a but)
“He was not counted righteous after circumcision BUT before he was circumcised.”
thanks again,
scott
Scott,
Thank you for catching that serious typo. I depend on brothers like you to help me see these things. Blessings.
Nick
Their only privileges before Christ were greater access to the Words of God, right? (I’m genuinely asking.)